When you apply for private health insurance in Germany, you hand over some of the most sensitive information you have. The law treats it that way too: health data is a special category under the GDPR, and an insurer may process it only on a narrow legal footing, usually your explicit consent. This guide explains what insurers ask, what they may do with your answers, who they may pass them to, and how you can use your rights if something looks wrong. It is written for employees, freelancers, students and families moving to or living in Germany.
TL;DR
- Health data is a special category under Art. 9 GDPR. Processing it is generally prohibited unless an exception applies, and for insurance risk assessment that is mostly your explicit consent.
- Insurers may collect data about you from third parties, such as doctors or hospitals, only if it is necessary and you have consented. You must be informed first and can object.
- You can withdraw consent at any time for the future, but without health data processing an insurer will in principle not be able to conclude or run your contract.
- You have rights of access, restriction, objection and erasure, and you can complain to a state data protection authority.
- Answer health questions fully and truthfully. Data protection protects you, but it does not replace your duty of disclosure.
Table of Contents
- Why health data gets special protection
- What you are asked when you apply
- Consent and release from professional secrecy
- What the Insurance Contract Act adds: § 213 VVG
- No purely automated rejection
- Who may receive your health data
- Using your data for prevention offers: the 2026 court ruling
- How long insurers keep your data
- Your rights as an applicant or policyholder
- If something goes wrong: complaints
- Disclosure duty and data protection work together
- Perspective: why we check data practices with you
- Getting help with the application
- FAQ
- Sources
Why health data gets special protection
Most personal data may be processed when there is a contract, a legal duty or a legitimate interest. Health data is different. Under Art. 9 GDPR, health data is a special category whose processing is in principle prohibited, and the exceptions have to be met one by one. For private insurers, the main exception is explicit consent under Art. 9(2)(a).
A data protection specialist at the DSB makes a point worth remembering: the difficulty in insurance is not the volume of data but its nature, and the permission comes from the customer, not from the law. In practice that means an insurer cannot simply rely on the fact that it needs data to price a policy. It needs your consent, and that consent has to be properly informed.
Germany adds national rules on top of the GDPR. The two that matter most for private health insurance are the Insurance Contract Act (Versicherungsvertragsgesetz, VVG) and the Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG), both covered below.
What you are asked when you apply
The health assessment (Gesundheitsprüfung) is not a medical appointment. As SIGNAL IDUNA explains, it is a questionnaire where you answer yes or no, and give details for every yes. The insurer uses your answers as the basis for a premium that fits your individual risk. Your duty to disclose applies from the moment you submit the application.
The questions differ by insurer. Two published examples show the range:
| Topic | INTER | SIGNAL IDUNA |
|---|---|---|
| Format | 12 self-declaration questions | 11 categories of questions |
| Current health and complaints | Current health status, chronic conditions | Complaints and illnesses over the last 3 years |
| Medication | Regular medication, last 3 years | Regular medication, last 3 years |
| Hospital stays | Hospital treatment, last 5 years | Hospital and rehabilitation stays, last 5 years |
| Outpatient care | Covered within the general questions | Outpatient treatments, last 3 years |
| Mental health and addiction | Not listed as separate periods in the source | Psychological or psychiatric treatment and addiction treatment, last 10 years |
| Body and senses | Height, weight, vision aids, dental status | Height, weight, vision aids, dental health, fertility treatment, HIV status |
The insurer uses the answers to estimate your personal health risk and set the contribution. That is the purpose the data is collected for, and it is the purpose your consent should be tied to.
If you want to prepare, our guide to the health assessment for applicants in Germany walks through the typical questions, and our article on pre-existing conditions and an anonymous pre-check explains how to test the waters before a formal application leaves your hands.
Consent and release from professional secrecy
Two declarations usually sit at the end of an application, and they do different jobs.
Consent to data processing. This is the Art. 9(2)(a) consent. The Hessen data protection authority states that insurers need the data subject's consent to collect, process and use health data for reviewing the application and for establishing, carrying out or ending the contract.
Release from professional secrecy (Schweigepflichtentbindung). Doctors and hospitals are bound by secrecy under § 203 of the criminal code. An insurer that wants to ask your doctor about you needs you to release the doctor from that duty. According to the privacy notice of Hallesche Krankenversicherung, it needs this release both to obtain data from doctors and to pass protected data, even the mere fact that a contract exists, to other entities such as assistance companies or IT service providers.
The same notice is candid about the trade-off. You are free to withhold or revoke consent, but without processing of health data the conclusion or performance of the insurance contract will in principle not be possible. That is not a trick. An insurer cannot price or pay out a health policy without looking at health information.

What the Insurance Contract Act adds: § 213 VVG
The most important national rule is § 213 VVG. It governs when a private insurer may collect your health data from other parties. In short:
- Who it may ask. Only doctors, hospitals and other medical institutions, care homes and carers, other private insurers, statutory health insurers, and accident insurance associations and authorities.
- Why. Only where the data is necessary to assess the risk or the duty to pay benefits, and where you have consented.
- When consent can be given. It may be given before you submit the application.
- Your say. You must be informed before any collection and may object. At any time you can demand that data be collected only after you have consented to each individual collection.
The DSB's expert notes that two conditions are most often misapplied in practice. One is the necessity requirement: a blanket authorisation to query "all treating doctors" is not enough. The other is your right to be informed, and to object, before each individual collection. If a form asks you to sign away everything in one line, you are entitled to ask the insurer how it squares with these rules.
No purely automated rejection
Many insurers now use digital application tools. That does not mean software alone can turn you down. According to the DSB, Art. 22 GDPR prohibits decisions with legal effect made exclusively by automated processing, and the rejection of an insurance application counts as such a decision. So a person at the insurer has to be involved in a rejection.
There is a narrow national exception. Section 37 BDSG lets insurers decide automatically on benefit claims where the request is fully granted, or where the decision relies on binding medical-fee rules. Where the request is not fully granted, the insurer must provide safeguards: human intervention, the chance to state your view, and the right to contest the decision. Such decisions may rely on health data only if appropriate and specific protective measures are in place.
Who may receive your health data
Your insurer does not work alone, and its privacy notice tells you who else may see your data. Typical recipients named in Hallesche's notice are medical assessors, service providers working on its behalf, reinsurers and intermediaries. It requires consent or a release from secrecy for the relevant disclosures, and it binds listed service providers by contract to data protection and data security rules.

Reinsurers deserve a word, since many people have never heard of them. Provinzial Krankenversicherung's notice says data goes to the reinsurer only to the extent necessary to assess risk or claims. The same notice says data may be passed to state bodies such as tax offices and social insurance carriers where a legal duty to disclose exists.
What insurers may not do is trade sensitive data among themselves for convenience. In 2025 the data protection authority of North Rhine-Westphalia opened investigations against ten insurers for exchanging personal data, including diagnoses, through a closed email distribution list for fraud detection in travel health insurance. The authority pointed out that the established industry information system HIS explicitly excludes highly sensitive health data. The case shows that regulators do act, and that even sector-wide fraud prevention has limits.
Using your data for prevention offers: the 2026 court ruling
One recent decision matters directly to policyholders. On 6 March 2026 the Federal Administrative Court (BVerwG, 6 C 7.24) ruled that private health insurers may not use diagnoses submitted with reimbursement claims to suggest preventive health programmes without consent.
The reasoning is nuanced. According to the same report, the court found that the analysis did not breach the general ban in Art. 9(1) GDPR, because it served health care purposes under Art. 9(2)(h) GDPR together with § 22(1)(1)(b) BDSG. Still, a commentary from Dr. Datenschutz explains that the processing was unlawful anyway, because the insurer's legitimate interest did not outweigh policyholders' interest in protecting highly sensitive health data.
For you, the practical lesson is simple. A well-meant wellness invitation based on your claims history is not automatically allowed. If you receive one and did not agree to it, you can ask the insurer on what legal basis it was sent.
How long insurers keep your data
Retention depends on whether your application led to a contract.
- No contract. Hallesche says it stores health data collected during risk assessment until the end of the third calendar year after the year of application. Other insurers set their own periods, so check the notice of the one you applied to.
- Contract concluded. Provinzial's notice says data is deleted once no longer needed, but retention can run up to the statutory limitation period of three to thirty years for claims against the company, plus legally required retention periods. It also names supervisory, commercial and tax law, IT security and fraud prevention as reasons for processing.
If you applied to several insurers while comparing, remember that each one holds its own copy of your answers. Ask each to confirm what it kept and for how long.
Your rights as an applicant or policyholder
The GDPR gives you a set of rights against every insurer. DAK-Gesundheit's rights overview and the data subject rights document of the statutory insurers' federation describe the same GDPR framework, which applies to private insurers as well.
| Right | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Withdraw consent | Possible at any time without giving reasons, with effect for the future. Earlier processing stays lawful. |
| Access (Art. 15) | You can ask what data the insurer holds about you. |
| Restriction (Art. 18) | Available if you contest accuracy, if processing is unlawful but you do not want deletion, if you need data for legal claims, or while an objection is pending. |
| Objection (Art. 21) | Lets you object to processing based on interests. Against direct advertising you need give no reason. |
| Erasure (Art. 17) | Applies if data is no longer necessary, was processed unlawfully, or consent was withdrawn. |
A few details save frustration.
Access is about data, not documents. The Federal Court of Justice held in ruling VI ZR 62/23 that Art. 15(3) GDPR gives no standalone right to copies of documents. The "copy" is of the personal data they contain, although excerpts or whole documents may be needed where context is essential for you to exercise your rights.
Letters count differently. In a ruling of 18 December 2025 (I ZR 115/25), the court held that your own letters to a controller are personal data in their entirety, while the controller's letters are personal data only where they contain identifiable information about you, as summarized by Freshfields.
Erasure has limits. An insurer that must keep records for legal reasons can refuse deletion for that period. Restriction can then be the more useful tool.
People arriving from abroad often use the access right in the other direction too, to obtain their own foreign medical records and give them to an insurer. We cover that in our article on using GDPR Art. 15 for foreign medical reports.
If something goes wrong: complaints
Start with the insurer. Write to its data protection officer, whose contact details are in the privacy notice, describe what happened, and set a reasonable deadline for a reply. Keep a copy.
If that does not resolve it, you can complain to a data protection authority. Germany has no single authority. As a rule, the state authority where the insurer has its registered seat handles private companies, while the federal commissioner (BfDI) covers federal bodies and certain companies with special jurisdiction. Check the official website of the relevant authority for its complaint form before you file.
Disclosure duty and data protection work together
Strong privacy rules sometimes tempt people to think they can keep quiet about a diagnosis. They cannot, and it would hurt you. SIGNAL IDUNA warns that missing or false answers can have significant financial and insurance-law consequences. The privacy framework protects how your answers are used. It does not change the questions you must answer.
Some habits that keep you on safe ground:
- Collect your records first. Request discharge letters and medication lists before filling in the form. Our list of documents for private health insurance in Germany helps.
- Answer within the periods asked: three years for medication, five for hospital stays, and longer for some mental health questions, depending on the insurer.
- Read the consent text before signing. Look at who may be asked, what is covered, and whether you can require single-case consent under § 213 VVG.
- Keep a copy of everything you submit.
- If you have a chronic condition, learn how it is treated in underwriting. Our guide on chronic illness and private health insurance explains the options.
Perspective: why we check data practices with you
We see the same worry from nearly every international client: "Who will see my medical history, and can I take it back?" It is a fair question, and the honest answer is that German law gives you more control than most people expect, as long as you use it at the right moment.
At Myhealthcarebroker we are independent and not tied to any single insurer, so we can compare how different companies phrase their consent texts and privacy notices, not only their premiums. That matters, because two policies with a similar price can handle your data quite differently. We explain the forms in clear English, so you know what you are signing before it goes anywhere.
Our advice is to treat privacy and the disclosure duty as one task. Gather your records, answer completely, and ask for the consent to be as specific as the law allows. You get a better outcome and fewer surprises when a claim arrives years later.
Marco
Getting help with the application
If you are comparing insurers and would like someone to read the health questions and consent forms with you in English, Myhealthcarebroker can do that. We compare private and public options across providers, check your eligibility first, and support you through the application and afterwards. The service is free to you, as we are paid a regulated commission by the insurer when a policy is signed.
You can start with an independent comparison or request a free quote for private health insurance. If you are not yet sure you qualify, our page on who is eligible for private health insurance is the best first stop. Our walkthrough on applying for private health insurance in Germany shows each step in order.
FAQ
Can a private health insurer access my medical records without asking me?
No. Under § 213 VVG it may collect data from doctors and similar bodies only where necessary for assessing risk or benefits, and only with your consent. You must be informed before collection and may object. You can also require that each collection happens only after you consent to it individually.
Can I withdraw my consent after I have signed?
Yes, at any time and without giving a reason, with effect for the future. Processing done before the withdrawal stays lawful. Keep in mind that without health data processing, an insurer will in principle be unable to conclude or run your contract.
How long is my data kept if I do not sign a policy?
It depends on the insurer. One published example keeps it until the end of the third calendar year after the year of application. Ask each insurer you applied to for its retention period and for confirmation of what it holds.
Can an insurer reject my application using only an algorithm?
No. Art. 22 GDPR prohibits decisions with legal effect made exclusively by automated processing, and the rejection of an application is one. A person at the insurer has to be involved in the decision.
Where do I complain about misuse of my health data?
First write to the insurer's data protection officer. If that fails, contact the state data protection authority responsible for the insurer's registered seat, using the complaint form on its official website.
Sources
- Datenschutz bei Versicherungen: § 213 VVG und Art. 9 (DSB)
- Gesundheitsprüfung Private Krankenversicherung (INTER)
- Gesundheitsprüfung: Alle Gesundheitsfragen erklärt (SIGNAL IDUNA)
- Datenschutzerklärung (Hallesche Krankenversicherung)
- Einwilligungs- und Schweigepflichtentbindungserklärung (Hessen data protection authority)
- § 37 BDSG
- Informationen zum Datenschutz (Provinzial Krankenversicherung)
- Datenkartell aufgedeckt (LDI NRW)
- BVerwG 6 C 7.24 (beck-aktuell)
- BVerwG zu Diagnoseauswertung (Dr. Datenschutz)
- Rights of data subjects (DAK-Gesundheit)
- Rechte der betroffenen Person (DVKA)
- BGH judgment VI ZR 62/23
- When is business data personal? (Freshfields)

