Privately insured people in Germany can receive money back in two main ways: a premium refund (Beitragsrückerstattung) for a year without claims, and a bonus that some tariffs pay out regardless of claims. Both lower what you effectively pay, but neither is automatic. They depend on your tariff, they can be reduced by submitting bills, and they change your tax return, because they shrink the health insurance contributions you can deduct.
This guide explains the types of payments, who gets what, how the tax side works, and how to decide between submitting a bill and keeping your refund. It is written for employees, freelancers and families who are new to the system as well as long-term residents.
TL;DR
- A premium refund is usually a reward for a claim-free year. Some tariffs also pay a fixed monthly or yearly bonus that does not depend on claims.
- Refunds and bonuses are tariff-specific. Many are not guaranteed, so read your tariff terms before you count on the money.
- Money you receive reduces the contributions you can deduct as special expenses (Sonderausgaben), so the net benefit is smaller than the headline amount.
- For small bills, compare the reimbursement with your likely refund after tax. Where the refund is larger, paying yourself can make sense. For large bills, claim.
- Comparing tariffs on their refund rules before you sign is easier than fixing the choice later.
Table of Contents
- The two kinds of payments back
- What insurers actually offer
- Conditions and the claim question
- How refunds and bonuses are taxed
- Employees: the employer subsidy changes the picture
- Submit the bill or keep the refund?
- How to pick a tariff with refunds in mind
- Our perspective
- Get the tariff comparison done for you
- FAQ
- Sources
The two kinds of payments back
People often lump everything under "bonus", but private insurers use two different mechanisms, and the difference matters for both tax and strategy.
Premium refund (Beitragsrückerstattung, BRE). The insurer returns part of your premium when you submit no claims for a calendar year. According to a comparison explainer on premium refunds, this benefit is voluntary on the insurer's side and not guaranteed. It typically takes one of two forms: a success-dependent refund, tied to the insurer's business results, or a flat payment for claim-free periods, often several monthly premiums.
Bonus payment (Bonuszahlung). A bonus is a payment rewarding a behavior or a tariff design, for example a fixed monthly amount built into a tariff, or a reward for documented health-conscious behavior such as preventive check-ups. SIGNAL IDUNA's guide to premium refunds explains that both refunds and bonuses reduce the premium you effectively pay (the Zahlbeitrag), and that insurers use them to encourage personal responsibility for health and awareness of costs.
A simple way to remember it: a refund is conditional on what you did not claim, while a bonus may be conditional on something else, or on nothing at all.

What insurers actually offer
The figures below come from insurers' own published pages. They show the range, not a promise for your tariff. Amounts differ by tariff, age group and employment status, and insurers update them.
| Type of payment | Example published by an insurer | What triggers it |
|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed refund | 10% for employees, self-employed people and freelancers in certain tariffs | No claims in the year |
| Success-dependent refund | Up to 50% depending on tariff and number of claim-free years, with up to 30% in total for employees in those tariffs (same insurer page) | No claims, plus the insurer's results |
| Health bonus | Up to €900 for claim-free years in selected tariffs | Claim-free years |
| Behavior bonus | Up to €300 for demonstrated health-conscious behavior, no claim-free requirement (same page) | Documented health activity |
| Cash-back | Up to six monthly premiums | Not using health services |
| Fixed monthly bonus tariff | €100 per insured person per month, €1,200 per year, half for children and teenagers | Paid monthly whether or not you submit invoices |
The last row is a different design from the others. In that tariff type, the annual bonus is deducted from your reimbursement if you do submit invoices. If you submit no invoices above the bonus amount, a further refund of up to €800 may be possible, according to the same insurer document (May 2026). So "bonus" and "refund" can sit in one tariff and interact.
Conditions and the claim question
The most common question is whether sending in a bill can cost you the refund. In most refund tariffs the answer is yes: the refund is built around a year without reimbursed claims, and a submitted invoice can reduce the refund or remove it for that year. The details vary by tariff, so the exact wording in your insurance conditions decides.
Things to look for in your tariff documents:
- Which claims count. Some tariffs treat preventive care or routine check-ups differently from treatment. Look for the list of exceptions.
- How the refund scales. Many refunds are staggered, with a percentage that grows with each claim-free year, or a flat number of monthly premiums.
- Whether it is guaranteed. Guaranteed amounts are written into the tariff. Success-dependent amounts are set each year by the insurer and can be lower or zero.
- Continuity and payment. Refunds usually assume the contract was in force throughout the year and premiums were paid. Confirm this in the conditions.
- Whether children are treated separately. Fixed bonuses, for example, may be halved for children and teenagers.
- Deductibles. If your tariff has a deductible (Selbstbehalt), small bills may fall below it anyway, which changes the math.
You will not find all of this in a sales brochure. It sits in the tariff conditions and the insurer's fee tables, which is one reason to have someone compare them with you before you sign.
How refunds and bonuses are taxed
In Germany you can deduct contributions to private health insurance for basic cover as special expenses. Our guide on whether private health insurance is tax-deductible in Germany covers the basics. What matters here is the reverse side: money coming back reduces the deduction.
Under § 10 Abs. 1 Nr. 3 EStG as summarized by Haufe (status 31 July 2026), premium refunds reduce the deductible special-expense amount. The Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) ruled on 16 December 2020 (X R 31/19) that bonuses paid by a private insurer reduce deductible special expenses as contribution refunds when they are paid regardless of whether the insured person incurred health costs. In other words, a bonus that does not depend on claims is treated like a refund.
The court has also explained the timing. In a 2016 decision, the BFH confirmed that refunded contributions are generally offset against like special expenses in the refund year. Any excess refund reduces deductions in the payment year. The court described this offset as tax-neutral in design, working for or against the taxpayer depending on the year.
What this means in practice:
- You do not pay tax on the refund as separate income in the usual case. Instead, your deductible contributions for that year are lower.
- The benefit you keep is the refund minus the tax value of the lost deduction. For someone with a high marginal rate, that gap is noticeable.
- The effect is the same whether you receive the money as a transfer or as a credit against your premium.
Tax rules are individual. If your return is complex, for example because of self-employment, a tax adviser (Steuerberater) or a Lohnsteuerhilfeverein can confirm how it applies to you. For deeper reading, see our explainer on the Sonderausgabenabzug and our guide to private health insurance tax savings.
Employees: the employer subsidy changes the picture
If you are an employee, your employer pays part of your premium (the Arbeitgeberanteil), as we explain in our guide to the employer contribution. A bonus paid to you alone therefore lowers your own share further. One insurer's bonus tariff documentation notes that this is particularly beneficial for employees, because the employer subsidy covers part of the premium while the monthly bonus goes to the employee.
The same document adds a tax detail: the bonus has to be deducted from the tax-deductible premium at the same percentage as the basic-cover share of the tariff, for example 79.59% for one of its tariffs. That is why the tax effect is smaller than the headline bonus.
Freelancers and self-employed people get no employer subsidy, so the refund reduces their full premium. Families and students should check whether children or dependents are insured under the same refund rules, since amounts for children are often lower. Our page on private health insurance for employees explains cost and eligibility in more detail.
Submit the bill or keep the refund?
This is the decision that actually costs or saves money. The logic is simple: you compare what you would get back if you submit the bill with what you would get if you keep the claim-free year.
The Haufe review of the tax rules states that bearing health costs yourself is advantageous when the after-tax contribution refund exceeds the actual costs. If the health costs are higher than the net refund, claim reimbursement instead. The Bundesfinanzhof has also confirmed (decision of 29 November 2017, X R 3/16) that costs you pay yourself are not insurance contributions and do not affect the special-expense deduction, and that you are free to choose between claiming and bearing the cost to obtain a higher refund.

A worked example
An insurer's bonus-tariff document gives a clear case. The tariff has a €1,200 annual bonus and a possible €500 premium refund, and you have a €1,500 invoice.
| Choice | Reimbursement | Premium refund | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Submit the invoice | €300 | €0 | €300 |
| Keep the invoice yourself | €0 | €500 | €500 |
By not submitting, you end up €200 better off in that example. Change the numbers, say a €4,000 invoice, and the answer reverses. A reimbursement of €2,800 beats a €500 refund easily.
A quick rule of thumb
- Small, routine bills such as a pharmacy purchase or a short consultation: compare the amount with your expected refund. If the refund is clearly larger and you have no other claims, paying yourself may be the better choice.
- Large or repeated treatment: claim it. A refund is never worth more than treatment costs you are entitled to have reimbursed.
- Ongoing conditions: you will likely claim every year anyway, so a tariff built on refunds is less relevant than one with strong benefits.
- Expected after-tax value: deduct the tax effect from the refund before you compare, since the refund lowers your deductible contributions.
The explainer on premium refunds adds that this choice is individual: it depends on your health, the refund relative to your bills, and whether your tariff has a deductible.
Also keep health in view. A refund system should never stop you from seeing a doctor when you need to. Seek care first and do the math afterward. For anything that concerns your health, speak to your doctor, not a spreadsheet.
How to pick a tariff with refunds in mind
A refund feature is one factor among many. When comparing tariffs, weigh it against the basics:
- Benefit level. Our tariff levels guide shows how basic, standard and premium tariffs differ.
- Premium now and later. A cheap tariff with a refund can still become expensive as you age or as your circumstances change.
- Guaranteed versus variable money. A guaranteed percentage is easier to plan with than a success-dependent one.
- Your expected claim pattern. Young and healthy people with few bills benefit most from refunds. People expecting a family, dental work or regular therapy often do better with richer benefits.
- Eligibility. Not everyone can choose private cover. Check the eligibility rules or run the eligibility check first.
For a deeper look at how the rebate works over a healthy year, see our guide to the premium rebate for a healthy year. To see what premiums look like for your age and income, the private health insurance calculator gives a first estimate.
Our perspective
We see the same pattern again and again with people who are new to Germany. Someone signs a private tariff because of an attractive refund, then discovers a year later that the refund was success-dependent, that a bill they submitted cost them the payment, and that their tax return showed a lower deduction than they expected.
None of this is a reason to avoid refund tariffs. It is a reason to read the refund rules the same way you read the benefits: which claims count, whether the amount is guaranteed, how it is split between employee and employer, and what the tax effect is.
Because Myhealthcarebroker is independent and not tied to a single insurer, we compare the refund and bonus terms across the major private insurers next to the benefits and the premium. We explain them in plain English, so you can judge whether a tariff fits your health, your income and your plans, before you apply. Our service is free to you.
Marco
Get the tariff comparison done for you
If you would rather not read tariff conditions line by line, Myhealthcarebroker compares private and public options across the major German insurers, including how each handles refunds and bonuses, and guides you from the eligibility check to the application in clear English. Our service is free to you. Start with our independent comparison or see private health insurance in Germany with advice in English.
If you are still deciding between systems, the public vs private calculator shows how the numbers compare, and our page on switching from public to private cover explains the steps.
FAQ
Is a premium refund guaranteed in private health insurance?
Not always. Some tariffs write a fixed percentage into the contract, while many refunds depend on the insurer's business success and are set each year. Check whether your tariff describes the refund as guaranteed or success-dependent.
Can submitting a single bill cost me the whole refund?
In many refund tariffs, a reimbursed claim can reduce or remove the refund for that year. Some tariffs exclude preventive care from this rule, and bonus tariffs work differently. Your tariff conditions state exactly which claims count.
Do I pay tax on a premium refund?
The usual effect is that your deductible health insurance contributions are lower in the year of the refund. According to a 2020 Federal Fiscal Court ruling, this also applies to insurer bonuses paid regardless of claims. Your tax adviser can tell you the exact effect on your return.
Is it worth paying small medical bills myself?
It can be, if your after-tax refund is larger than the bills you would otherwise submit. If your costs are higher than the net refund, claim reimbursement. Never delay care to protect a refund.
Do bonuses work the same for employees and freelancers?
The rules differ by tariff. Employees share the premium with their employer, so a bonus lowers their own share. Self-employed people pay the full premium themselves, and some insurers publish separate refund rates for each group.
Sources
- Premium refund in private health insurance, explainer
- SIGNAL IDUNA guide to premium refunds and bonuses
- Allianz page on premium refunds
- Debeka cash-back page
- Hallesche bonus tariffs information sheet
- Bundesfinanzhof, decision of 16 December 2020 (X R 31/19)
- Bundesfinanzhof, decision of 3 August 2016
- Bundesfinanzhof, decision of 29 November 2017 (X R 3/16)
- Haufe, literature review on § 10 EStG (status 31 July 2026)

